top of page
Search

Squat vs Deadlift for Low Back Pain and Endurance Athletes What Science Says

scottrichardsonpt
Nov 11
9 min read

The squat and the deadlift are often treated like rival lifts, but they solve different problems. One trains the body to sit down and stand up under load. The other trains the body to hinge, brace and pick something up. For a personal training client with non-specific lower back pain, that difference matters.


It also matters for endurance athletes. Runners, triathletes and Ironman athletes do not need to train like powerlifters, but they do need strong hips, legs and trunk muscles that can tolerate repeated force for hours.


The short answer is this: most people benefit from learning both patterns, but not everyone needs the barbell versions straight away. The aim is not to “fix” pain with one magic exercise. The aim is to build capacity, confidence and useful strength.


This article is informational only and is not a diagnosis or medical treatment plan. Persistent, worsening or nerve-related back pain should be assessed by a qualified clinician.


Wide-angle view of a person practising a goblet squat beside a trap bar in a gym
Squats and deadlifts train different strength patterns, but both can be scaled.

What the research says about exercise and low back pain


For non-specific lower back pain, the best evidence does not point to one perfect exercise. It points to progressive exercise, consistency and matching the programme to the person.


A large Cochrane review by Hayden and colleagues looked at exercise therapy for chronic low back pain. It included hundreds of trials and thousands of participants, making it one of the larger evidence sources in this area. The review found that exercise therapy probably reduces pain compared with minimal care or usual care, although the average effects are often modest.


Key reference


Hayden JA et al. Exercise therapy for chronic low back pain. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. PMID: 34580864


That matters because many personal training clients use the phrase “bad back” as if the back is fragile. The evidence suggests the opposite approach is often useful: gradual loading, sensible progression and movement variety.


A more specific review looked at posterior-chain resistance training for chronic low back pain. This is relevant to deadlifts because the deadlift is a classic posterior-chain lift. The review suggested that posterior-chain resistance training can improve pain, disability and muscle strength compared with some general exercise or walking programmes.


Key reference


Tataryn N et al. Posterior-chain resistance training compared to general exercise and walking programmes for the treatment of chronic low back pain in the general population. Sports Medicine Open. PMID: 33713204


That does not mean everyone with back pain should immediately pull a heavy barbell from the floor. It means the muscles that extend and support the hips and spine can be trained, and that training can be part of a helpful plan.


Another systematic review and meta-analysis by Searle and colleagues found that strength/resistance exercise and coordination or stabilisation exercise were among the exercise approaches that helped chronic low back pain.


Key reference


Searle A et al. Exercise interventions for the treatment of chronic low back pain. British Journal of Sports Medicine. PMID: 25681408


So, the science supports exercise. It supports strength work. It supports posterior-chain loading. It does not say that the squat or deadlift must look one exact way for every person.


The squat and deadlift load the body differently


The squat and the deadlift both train the legs, hips and trunk, but the load sits in a different place and the body organises itself differently around that load.


Lift

Where the load usually sits

Main movement pattern

Common emphasis

What the trunk does

Squat

On the back, front of shoulders, or held in the hands

Knee and hip bend together

Quads, glutes, adductors, trunk bracing

Resists folding forward under axial load

Deadlift

In the hands, usually below the hips

Hip hinge with some knee bend

Glutes, hamstrings, spinal erectors, lats, grip

Resists spinal flexion while the hips extend


What the squat does


A squat asks the body to control a loaded descent and then drive back up. Depending on the style, the load may sit:


  • Across the upper back in a back squat

  • On the front of the shoulders in a front squat

  • In front of the chest in a goblet squat

  • In each hand during a split squat or dumbbell squat


The squat tends to involve more knee bend than a deadlift. That usually means more work for the quadriceps. The hips and glutes still work hard, especially in deeper squats or wider stances.


For the lower back, the squat is not “bad” by default. The spinal muscles work mainly to keep the trunk stable. A high-bar or front squat usually allows a more upright torso. A low-bar squat uses more hip hinge and can place a greater demand on the back and hips.


For a client with non-specific low back pain, a goblet squat, box squat or split squat can be a good starting point because the load is easier to control and can be kept lighter.


What the deadlift does


A deadlift asks the body to hinge at the hips, brace the trunk and push the ground away while holding the load in the hands.


The deadlift usually places more demand on:


  • Hip extensors, especially the glutes

  • Hamstrings

  • Spinal erectors

  • Lats and upper back

  • Grip

  • Abdominal bracing


The lower back is involved, but it should not be doing the whole job. In a well-taught deadlift, the spine stays relatively stable while the hips and legs produce the movement.


Load placement is the big difference. In a squat, the load often sits on the body. In a deadlift, the load hangs from the arms. This changes the challenge. The deadlift creates a strong demand to resist the bar pulling the torso forward. That is why lighter hinge variations such as Romanian deadlifts, rack pulls, kettlebell deadlifts and trap bar deadlifts can be useful stepping stones.


What this means for non-specific lower back pain


Non-specific lower back pain means there is no clear single structural cause, such as a fracture, infection or major nerve compression. That does not mean the pain is imaginary. It means the pain experience is influenced by several factors, including tissue sensitivity, strength, sleep, stress, previous injury, fear of movement and workload.


For many clients, the problem is not that they should avoid loading. The problem is that they need the right entry point.


A sensible approach looks like this:


  1. Find tolerable movement first

    A person might start with bodyweight box squats, supported split squats or hip hinges to a wall.


  1. Load the pattern without chasing pain

    Mild discomfort may be acceptable for some people, but sharp, spreading or worsening pain is not the goal.


  2. Progress range, load or volume one at a time

    Do not increase depth, weight and weekly sets all in the same week.


  1. Train the hips and trunk together

    The back rarely works alone. Strong glutes, hamstrings, quads and trunk muscles help share load.


  2. Build confidence through repetition

    Fear of bending can keep people guarded. Good coaching can restore trust in normal movement.


This is where Squat vs Deadlift for Low Back Pain and Endurance Athletes What Science Says becomes practical rather than theoretical. The right question is not “Which lift is safer?” A better question is “Which version can this person perform well today, and how can we progress it?”


Should everyone do both squats and deadlifts?


Most people should train both patterns in some form. That does not mean everyone must back squat or conventional deadlift from the floor.


A general population client may get all the benefit they need from:


  • Goblet squats

  • Split squats

  • Step-ups

  • Trap bar deadlifts

  • Romanian deadlifts

  • Kettlebell deadlifts

  • Hip thrusts

  • Loaded carries


The squat pattern helps with sitting, standing, stairs, lunging and getting up from the floor. The deadlift pattern helps with lifting objects, hinging, carrying, gardening, picking up children and moving with a stable trunk.


For lower back pain, the choice often comes down to tolerance.


A client who dislikes forward bending may start with squats and raised-handle deadlifts. A client whose knees dislike deep flexion may begin with hip hinges and box squats. A client who feels anxious under a barbell may use dumbbells, kettlebells or a trap bar.


The goal is not to force the body into a famous lift. The goal is to train the pattern in a way the person can repeat, recover from and progress.


Why endurance athletes should care


Endurance athletes often ask a fair question: if the sport is running, cycling or swimming, why spend time lifting?


Because endurance sport is not just cardiovascular. Every foot strike, pedal stroke and climb is a strength event repeated many times. When strength improves, each repetition can cost slightly less.


Research on strength training for runners suggests it can improve running economy. A systematic review with meta-analysis by Balsalobre-Fernández and colleagues reported that strength training improved running economy in trained runners.


Key reference


Balsalobre-Fernández C et al. The effects of strength training on running economy in highly trained runners. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research. PMID: 26694507


For a triathlete or Ironman athlete, this matters because small efficiency gains can add up over long distances. Strength training may help with:


  • Better force production during hills and accelerations

  • Improved tolerance to repeated impact

  • Stronger hip extension late in a race

  • Better posture on the bike

  • Reduced strength loss during heavy training blocks

  • More resilience when fatigue changes movement quality


How squats help endurance athletes


Squats are valuable because they train the legs through knee and hip extension. That transfers well to running uphill, climbing stairs, getting out of the saddle on the bike and producing force through a bent knee.


Useful squat variations for endurance athletes include:


  • Front squats

  • Goblet squats

  • Rear-foot elevated split squats

  • Step-ups

  • Single-leg squats to a box


Single-leg squat patterns are especially relevant because running is a series of single-leg landings. Triathletes do not need to max out these lifts to benefit. They need enough strength to hold form when tired.


How deadlifts help endurance athletes


Deadlifts train hip extension and posterior-chain strength. This is useful for runners and triathletes because the glutes and hamstrings help control the hip, stabilise the pelvis and contribute to propulsion.


Useful deadlift variations include:


  • Trap bar deadlifts

  • Romanian deadlifts

  • Single-leg Romanian deadlifts

  • Kettlebell deadlifts

  • Rack pulls


The deadlift also teaches bracing. That can help an endurance athlete maintain trunk position during long runs, technical trails and prolonged cycling efforts.


The trap bar deadlift is often a strong option for endurance athletes because it sits between a squat and a deadlift. The load is held in the hands, but the torso can stay more upright than in a conventional barbell deadlift.


Eye-level view of an endurance athlete performing a trap bar deadlift in a simple training gym
Trap bar deadlifts can bridge the gap between squat strength and hip-hinge strength.

How to programme squats and deadlifts without irritating the back


For personal training clients and endurance athletes, the best programme is usually boring in a good way. It uses manageable loads, clear technique and slow progression.


A simple weekly strength structure might look like this:


Goal

Squat pattern

Deadlift pattern

Notes

General fitness with back sensitivity

Goblet squat, 2 to 3 sets of 8 to 10

Kettlebell deadlift, 2 to 3 sets of 8

Keep effort moderate and technique consistent

Runner in base training

Split squat, 3 sets of 6 to 8 each side

Romanian deadlift, 3 sets of 6 to 8

Avoid heavy lifting before key run sessions

Triathlete in heavy training

Front squat, 2 to 3 sets of 4 to 6

Trap bar deadlift, 2 to 3 sets of 4 to 6

Keep volume low enough to recover from swimming, cycling and running

Return from back flare-up

Box squat, 2 sets of 8

Raised-handle deadlift, 2 sets of 6 to 8

Start with a pain-tolerable range and build gradually


For strength work, the final reps should feel challenging but controlled. Grinding, breath-holding panic and form breakdown are poor trade-offs for most non-competitive lifters.


A useful rule is to finish most sets with two or three reps in reserve. That gives the body a strength signal without turning every session into a test.


For endurance athletes, timing also matters. Heavy squats or deadlifts the day before intervals, a long run or a big brick session can make the key endurance work worse. Place strength sessions after easier endurance days or after quality sessions when the next day allows recovery.


Technique priorities that matter more than the exact variation


No single cue works for everyone, but a few principles are reliable.


For squats:


  • Keep the whole foot connected to the floor

  • Let the knees bend and travel naturally

  • Use a depth that can be controlled

  • Keep the ribcage and pelvis stacked

  • Choose a load position that feels stable


For deadlifts:


  • Start with the load close to the body

  • Hinge from the hips rather than rounding from the spine

  • Brace before lifting

  • Push the floor away

  • Stand tall without leaning back at the top


A neutral spine does not mean the spine never moves. It means the lifter avoids uncontrolled end-range positions under more load than they can manage.


The practical takeaway


Squats and deadlifts are not enemies. They are complementary tools.


The squat loads the body more through a knee-and-hip bending pattern, often with the weight supported on the body. The deadlift loads the body through a hip-hinge pattern, often with the weight hanging from the hands. Both require trunk stiffness. Both train the lower body. Both can help build confidence and capacity when introduced at the right level.


For non-specific lower back pain, the evidence supports exercise, resistance training and progressive loading. It does not support fear-based avoidance of normal movement. For endurance athletes, squats and deadlifts can improve the strength qualities that support running, cycling and long-duration performance.


The best choice is not squat or deadlift. It is the right squat variation, the right deadlift variation and the right dose for the person in front of you.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page